I've finally had some time to really play with the device. I ran the NYC Marathon a couple of Sundays ago, and have finally caught up on all the stuff waiting for me back home.
Initial thoughts: Big device. Maybe not as big as my old i700, but have you all gone back to see the size of the Touch? Big difference. Honestly, I think it could be a little smaller...take off the D-Pad and replace it with arrows. However, its not too big--essentially same as the
iPhone.
Love the rubber backing on the battery cover. For those that like to go naked, it won't slip. Rarely will you see a naked
iPhone, and that is one of the big reasons.
Charging cord too short. Really, its not very practical...
I actually like the SD card hidden. Now that they are big in memory, I rarely switch them out. And I can't tell you how many I have lost due to ejections from dropping the phone, being in my briefcase, etc...
Set up was super easy. But I use Google---I have a Gmail acct, and had already set up Google sync to sync my work Outlook calendar to my Google calendar. Same for contacts. So that worked well for me. Email set up easy. I went ahead and sync'd to my company's Exchange acct as well. No problem.
(the problem is that unlike the
iPhone exchange interface, I can't access folders off the Droid like I can on the
iPhone. Basically I can just pull off email and send it, not have true exchange access to my folders. Same with Yahoo)
Most of my comparison will be to the
iPhone. I have a 3GS on AT&T---its main competitor.
Screen--flippin' gorgeous. Big difference to anyone who looks at it. Even if you adjust
iPhone's brightness, the Droid is superior. Wow.
OS--honestly, I don't think it is hard to figure out. It may be a little tricky to a dumbphone user, but then again, any smartphone is tricky to dumbphone users. Even an
iPhone. I gave it (the Droid) to my 13yo son to play with (who has an
iPhone). He was navigating, downloading apps, checking YouTube, checking ringtones, etc... right off the bat. And he's not a tech geek like his old man. Even my wife could get her way around to find a contact and dial them.
Speed---again, wow. Side by side, 4 bars on each device (
iPhone 3GS and Droid). Pulls up webpages and YouTube much faster. Google maps is faster. That's the network you say? Same games like PapiJump is faster on the Droid... (plus that's one of the advantages of the Droid, right---being on Verizon)
Apps---they have a lot, but honestly, the
iPhone is way ahead there. Way ahead. But that should improve with time.
Keyboard ---love having it, but I can't seem to type very fast on it. Maybe I've gotten used to screen typing, but I can't build up speed. I typed much faster on my TouchPro's keyboard.
Buttons---seem fine to me. I agree the power/sleep button is a little cumbersome, but its tolerable.
I like having the blinking light notifications. I miss that on the
iPhone. And they are not too bright/big. (it won't light up the room at night like some of my other devices did)
Media---again, much better on the
iPhone (if you are an iTunes/iPod user---but who isn't?) I haven't taken the time to load one of the mentioned media browsers/sync'ers, but who wants to do that? Most just want to sync it to their iTunes. That is a big drawback IMHO. If people want this as an
iPhone alternative, they want their media with them. I think VzW should make it clear how to download a program to move all the media to the Droid. However, since most people use iTunes, they need a way to get iTunes media to the Droid....
Overall, I think this phone is a big winner. It is fast, has a fabulous screen, and has VzW's network. How I miss the network! I'm going to test it further--only doing freebie apps right now. In comparing the two, I really found that the Droid is very much like the
iPhone---more so than any other device I have used. Probably because Android is the closest to the OS of
iPhone, and it can match the speed/screen. (I haven't played with a Pre, but equus can comment on that.) I like it, I would recommend it, and am excited to see the evolution. It should far surpass some of VzW's recent offerings, because people are looking for
iPhone-like devices, not business driven Blackberrys.