I don't even have my Treo yet, but knowing the months of agony I spent before deciding on a Bellagio case for the Clie (and before that a Vaja for a Visor), I need to start thinking about this now.

I've made it through about 1/2 the pages in this post and I'll keep reading, but I'm not seeing the answer here yet... so I'm hoping you case experts can help me out.

Here are my conditions:
1. Female - never wear a belt... ever! But, usually, I have something a case could be clipped to (purse, waistband) if the clip isn't too bulky.

2. Am unlikely to go jogging with it or anything (jogging... bahahaha), but I am a klutz who is always dashing off to class or a meeting and often have some of my herd of children jostling me. So, I need it to protect pretty well.

3. Did I say I'm a klutz? I used my clie exactly 1 day without a case on it and managed to drop it in a stairwell onto a nice industrial linoleum over concrete floor, fugging the finish. So, I will want something on it to keep me from throwing it on the ground regularly.

4. I loved my Vaja and Bellagio cases, but since then have decided not to buy leather (personal, so it isn't an indictment of anyone else at all... rock on with the cow hide! ) and I'm not seeing many non leather cases.

5. I work in an academic setting, so it doesn't have to be super professional, but then again, being a prof. is dweeby enough, so I try not to add to my dorkitude more than I need to.

Given all of that, I would take any advice you've got!