So,
1) Both look as if they were cut from the mold with fingernail clippers.
2) They feel exactly the same.
3) They look exactly the same except the Boxwave has a few additional cutouts in the back that serve no porpose.
4) They fit exactly the same.
5) They both bounce right back into shape when stretched.
6) All the buttons are easy to use with both of them.
7) The skins are the same thickness.
The only thing I can guess is that Boxwave skin case owners claim that the Boxwave skin is better because they want to justify the extra $10.00 they wasted for no reason
I gotta tell ya I love the grippy feeling of the silicon skin. The button use is not hindered a bit and they look pretty good.
The arrows below point to the sloppy cuts on the cases. Almost all the edges are sloppy but the ones with the arrows are really sloppy.