I just got the Brando today. Overall, I like it except for one MAJOR issue. I use the belt clip but the brando version is a real pain to use. It is a molded plastic hook rather than a spring loaded clip. Almost impossible to put on one-handed. You have to pull the hook out and then put it on. I inquired about a different belt clip and they said there is no other option.

Other than that, I like the crush resistance. My Piel Frama was always getting squished by my lap belt. I don't think either would do much to protect from a side/corner impact.

Having the speaker exposed is a real plus too. The Piel muffled rings pretty bad. Slightly thicker than the Piel but not too noticeable on my hip.

__________________
xv6600, EVDO, itrek, iguidance