That item (#2) concerns me. It sounds very easy for something to catch the bottom of the phone and flip it out of the clip and onto the floor. Since it comes out from the bottom, that sounds like a possible accident waiting to happen.

Edit: Looking at your photos the ProClip doesn't look very secure. I gave up on the clips (anyone want to by a Seidio cradle clip?) and went with the Covertec horizontal pouch.HERE . It sits real close to the belt, works with eGrips and isn't affected by my, er, waistline. Only complaint is you have to "lock" the phone so buttons don't get pressed when putting it in the case.